Should you eat less protein to live longer?


Hey Reader,​

Maybe you’ve been working on eating more protein.

You added eggs at breakfast, started buying Greek yogurt, or finally found a protein shake that doesn’t taste like sweetened drywall.

Then TIME publishes this headline:

“Eating Less Protein May Help You Age Better and Live Longer.”

Seriously?

Nutrition advice can feel like someone keeps moving the finish line. Just when you think you’re doing something helpful, another headline makes you question it.

So I looked at the research behind this one.

The paper was a review of more than 350 studies on protein and aging.

Every controlled experiment showing that protein restriction can extend lifespan has been conducted in nonhuman organisms, including yeast, insects, fish, and rodents.

The review also included a handful of small human diet trials lasting approximately 4 to 8 weeks. Those trials found some interesting changes in blood sugar, insulin sensitivity, energy use, body fat, and the way cells respond to nutrients.

Human lifespan and long-term quality of life were outside the scope of those trials. We still don’t know whether deliberately eating less protein helps people live longer or age better.

That’s a pretty big missing piece.

Why do I still encourage my clients to eat more protein?

Because many of the women I work with frequently don’t eat enough protein, especially at breakfast or lunch.

Protein can help make meals more satisfying. It also gives your body what it needs to repair and maintain muscle.

And if you’re a woman in your 30s, 40s, 50s, or 60s +, protecting that muscle deserves some attention.

Muscle and strength gradually become harder to maintain as we age. Hormonal changes through perimenopause and menopause can add another layer to that challenge.

Muscle helps you:

  • Preserve more lean tissue when you lose weight
  • Maintain strong bones and better balance
  • Recover from workouts and everyday activity
  • Support healthy blood sugar
  • Climb stairs, carry groceries, hike, travel, garden, and get off the floor without planning an elaborate exit strategy

The target is enough protein to support your body. There’s no prize for adding protein to your water, shampoo, chips, cereal, and every snack that wanders through your kitchen.

For many women, a useful place to start is:

  • Include 20 to 40 grams of protein, or about 1 to 2 palm-sized servings, at each meal
  • Strength train 2 to 3 times per week
  • Eat plenty of plant foods
  • Adjust the amount based on your body size, activity, health, and goals

And when another nutrition headline makes you wonder whether you need to redo your entire grocery list, ask:

  1. Was the research conducted in humans?
  2. Did it measure the outcome promised in the headline?
  3. Were the people studied anything like me?

The research behind this headline gives scientists an interesting question to keep studying.

For women in their 30s, 40s, 50s, and 60s +, we already have good reasons to eat enough protein and protect our strength.

Your muscles are working for you every time you carry groceries, climb stairs, pick up your kids or grandkids, or haul six shopping bags inside because making two trips would be unreasonable.

They’re worth feeding.

Until Next Time,

P.S. Sharing is caring! If you know someone who could benefit from this, feel free to forward it on to them. And if you were forwarded this message, you can get on my email list too—just subscribe here. Help spread the wellness love!💛

600 1st Ave, Ste 330 PMB 92768, Seattle, WA 98104-2246
​Unsubscribe · Preferences​

TRH Coaching

Evidence-based fitness and nutrition coaching for women who are tried of knowing what to do....but struggling to actually do it consistently.

Read more from TRH Coaching

Hey Reader, Are you someone who plans every dinner for the week before Monday even rolls around? Or does that level of planning make you want to rebel and order takeout purely on principle? I’m definitely closer to the second camp. I like having food planned and available. I just don’t particularly enjoy knowing that Tuesday at 6:00 PM has been officially assigned Taco Bowls three days in advance. And I’m certainly not making Pan-Seared Chilean Sea Bass on a random Wednesday night. 😉 The good...

Hey Reader, Let’s face it, as human beings we like to know what other people are doing. What they buy, how they spend their time, what they eat. Maybe there’s a tiny bit of nosiness involved. ;) When it comes to food, though, that curiosity can actually be useful. Seeing what someone else eats can give you ideas and make nutrition feel a little more concrete. Recently, one of my clients told me she’d love to see what I eat. She wasn’t looking for a meal plan to copy, she was just curious...

Hey Reader, I’ve taken on a few new personal training clients this month, which means I’ve had several conversations lately about soreness. Some of my clients have been pretty sore after their first few workouts. Others? Barely sore at all. And some people actually like that sore feeling. It can make a workout feel satisfying, like, “Yep, I definitely did something yesterday.” There’s nothing wrong with that. The question is whether soreness actually tells us how effective a workout was. Does...